Tales by Cole – Episode 59 – “A Serial Sinner Among the Amish”



A NOTE TO LISTENERS: The episode available here is ad-supported. To access this and other episodes of this program ad-free, sign up to become a Patron today at Chilling Tales for Dark Nights. In our Patrons-only members area, you’ll get access to HQ MP3 copies of all of our podcast episodes – totally free of advertisements – plus access to hundreds of stand-alone audio horror productions dating back to 2012. You’ll also be helping to support this program and the team that bring it to you every week.  Thank you for your support!

Welcome to Episode 59 of Tales by Cole, starring Cole Weavers.

The Amish community is known for their fanatical wholesomeness, as well as their authoritarian rules – rules which not everyone can conform to. Eli Stutzman, Jr. was one such person who didn’t agree with the rules, but what happened when his rebellion against the Amish Church and his father went too far? Did the Amish make him the man he was? Or was he born that way?


The version of this podcast which is made freely available here is ad-supported. To enjoy a premium, ad-free version of this episode, as well as our extensive audio archive of other terrifying tales, please sign up for a Patrons account today.

Podcast executive produced and directed by: Cole Weavers
Podcast produced by Cole Weavers
Podcast hosted by: Cole Weavers
Performed by: Cole Weavers
Sound design by: Cole Weavers
Script by: Cole Weavers

Audio program © 2021 Cole Weavers – All Rights Reserved. No reproduction or use of this content is permitted without the express written consent of Cole Weavers.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments